Comments, the voice of experience and discussion regarding strength and muscle-building from a 67 year-old with a masters in exercise physiology and more strength and muscle mass NOW than when a competitive weightlifter over forty years ago

Thursday, February 11, 2010

THAT REP THING - PART I


It is generally believed that using a weight that allows more than 30
reps does VERY LITTLE towards building REAL STRENGTH - in ANY
exercise! Judging from my own experience, I'm not so sure that's true.
While there is definitely NOT a one-to-one CORRELATION between
a 30 rep increase in strength and a ONE REPETITION MAX increase in
strength, there is SOME. For the older trainee who may not be willing
to spend the time on the extensive warm-ups necessary for LOW-REP,
HEAVY WEIGHT TRAINING, this is good news. The following are some
observations regarding the heavy-or-light dilemma garnered over my own
FIFTY YEARS of weight training. This is the way things WORKED FOR
ME, so all statements should be regarded as "FOOD FOR THOUGHT"
rather than as universal truths:

1) I definitely make better strength gains in deadlifts, quadriceps
strength and ANY PULLING EXERCISE INVOLVING THE LATS
when I keep the reps above 20. The strength gained in those bodyparts
involved DOES seem to CORRELATE ONE HUNDRED PERCENT
with gains in strength with heavy weights and low reps. In other words,
if I increase 25 lbs. in my 20 rep max in, say, the deadlift, I can be
sure I'll be up 25 lbs. in my 5 rep max as well. I don't know how
these higher reps might affect my ONE REP MAX simply because
I never do maximum singles.

2) For all pressing motions the correlation only seems about half
that close. In other words, an increase in what I can seated press
for 20 reps might only give me a 5 lb. -- OR LESS -- increase in
my five-rep or three-rep max. But the thing is . . . it's STILL AN
INCREASE; and I'm able to obtain it without all the shoulder and
elbow DISCOMFORT AND STRAIN that the heavier, lower rep
training VIRTUALLY GUARANTEES.

3) No matter what exercise or bodypart I apply higher rep training
to, I can continue to move the weight up for many, many workouts
in a row, while heavy, low rep training stalls out and "STALES
OUT" after only five or six workouts - ALWAYS. This may be a
psychological thing, but I also think it has to do with the constant
strain on 62 year-old joints and tendons. The above illustration,
by the way, is a very accurate and NOT EXAGERATED depiction of
Gustav Fristensky (1901??), who did an above-average amount of
high rep training as well as the heavy stuff.

More on this in PART II.

No comments:

Post a Comment


Followers

About Me

My photo
Troy, MI, United States
Born 3/21/47 *** First workout was Christmas Day, 1960 *** Never stopped, never looked back *** No steroids, ever *** 5'9, 215 lbs *** Arms first hit 18 inches at age 60 *** First World Record (age group, strict curl) at age 64 *** Published novelist with St. Martin's Press with two books endorsed and recommended by Stephen King *** Married, four grown kids: an Artist in Residence appointee for Yellowstone National Park (wife); a winner of the CFO of the Year for the State of Michigan award (son, John); an orthopedic surgeon and Carnegie Medal for Heroism recipient (son, Bob); an engineer who can stict curl 200 lbs at 197 bdwt (son, David); and the RN everybody falls in love with and asks for when in the hospital (daughter, Katie)***